Unit VIII
Article Critique
Select two current, professional journal articles that are at least four pages
in length. You must write a critical assessment of the articles for this
assignment. Keep in mind, the research databases found in the CSU Online Library
are a great source for quick exploration of thousands of articles.
In preparation, follow the guidelines established below:
Find two articles (that are less than five years old) that pertain to team
building or improving team performance and annotate, in your own words, as you
read. Note the authors’ main points and thesis statements. The critiques should
be approximately two to three pages EACH in length (not counting the title and
reference page). The assignment is due at the completion of Unit VIII. Plan
early to avoid missing the deadline.
Part I: Introduction
Start EACH critique with the following information: the author’s name, the
article title, and the author’s thesis statement.
Part II: Summary
Summarize the author’s purpose and main points; providing examples for clarity
of understanding the author’s intended implications. Share key topics that
support the author’s focus for this article. Provide ample details to enlighten
the reader as to what the article is implying for audiences who are seeking
research data in regards to team building and/or the different types of teams
(e.g., virtual, temporary, traditional, or innovative).
Part III: Review and Evaluate
To critically review the article, ask the following questions:
What are the credentials/areas of expertise of the author? Did the author use
appropriate methods to gather the evidence? Did the author use accurate
evidence? Does the author’s use and interpretation of this evidence lead the
reader to the same conclusion? Did the author build a logical argument? Is
there other evidence that would support a counter-argument? Was the author
successful in making his/her point?
Part IV: Conclusion
State whether you agree with the author or not. Back up your decisions by stating
your reasons. Give a general opinion of the work. Explain what you learned from
reading the article and if you would recommend it to a friend/coworker.
Format your paper using APA style. Refer to resources provided in the Student
Portal. Use your own words and expressions to write the critique. Include
citations and references as needed to avoid plagiarism. The paper should
consist of two to three pages of body paragraphs for EACH critique, one title
page, and one reference page (as the final page).
