Week 6 discussion
Discussion Part One
You are attending a large continuing education conference
for primary care providers. In the audience are physicians, nurse
practitioners, and physician assistants from all over the country. Seated at
your table are physicians and nurse practitioners. Following the lecture on teamwork
and interdisciplinary collaboration, a debate ensues at your table. One
physician stated:
I am against nurse
practitioners who want to take my job. There is a huge difference in the two
professions. Primary-care physicians receive extensive and diverse medical
education and clinical experience. The nurse practitioner should not function
as an independent healthcare provider…they should only function in an
integrated practice arrangement under the direction and responsible supervision
of a practicing, licensed physician.
Discussion Question:
How would you respond to the physician’s statements? Use
logical reasoning and evidence from the literature to support your response.
Discussion Part Two
A fellow NP at the table responded:
An increasing number
of practices are scrapping the traditional one-on-one doctor-patient
relationship. Instead, patients are receiving care from a group of health
professionals who divide up responsibilities that once would have largely been
handled by the doctor in charge. While the supervising physician still directly
oversees patient care, other medical professionals—nurse practitioners,
physician assistants and clinical pharmacists—are performing more functions.
These include adjusting medication dosage, ensuring that patients receive tests
and helping them to manage chronic diseases.
Discussion Question:
What are your thoughts on interprofessional collaboration?
Provide evidence to support your response.
Discussion Part Three
The Federal Trade Commission has weighed in on several state
battles over scope of practice, arguing that physician groups have no valid
reason for blocking such laws other than to thwart competition.
Discussion Question:
How does “restraint of trade” apply to NP practice
limitations? Provide evidence for your response.
