Week 3 HRMN 362
Instructions
Written Assignment 1
(25 points) 3-4 pages, not including cover or References
pages
Locate an article describing a collective bargaining
situation that has arisen within the past two years. This article should be
from a newspaper, an academic journal, or a credible online news source. Use a
minimum of two additional references to support your discussion and to respond
to the questions in the assignment.
a. Using APA guidelines, state the proper citation for the
article.
b. State the nature of the collective bargaining dispute.
c. What are the underlying causes of the dispute?
d. What economic or ethical pressures has each side
attempted to use to prevail in the dispute?
e. If there is any evidence of any illegal or unethical
conduct on either side, describe it in detail.
f. Was the dispute resolved? If so, how?
g. What, if any, role was played by third parties in
resolving this bargaining dispute? What was the identity of the third party?
h. In retrospect, could this dispute have been resolved in a
more constructive fashion? If so, how?
RUBRIC FOR WRITTEN ASSIGNMENT 1
Criteria 1
Exceeds Expectations
5 points
Meets Expectations
4 points
Meets Some Expectations
3 points
Does Not Meet Expectations
2 points
Not Included
0 points
Addresses nature of the collective bargaining dispute and
the underlying causes of the dispute.
Discusses the environment, trends, influences, challenges,
current trends
Effectively addresses the nature of the collective
bargaining dispute and the underlying causes of the dispute.
Discusses the environment, trends, influences, challenges,
current trends.
Addresses the nature of the collective bargaining dispute
and the underlying causes of the dispute although not as comprehensively as it
should be.
Discusses the environment, trends, influences, challenges,
current trends; however, makes some indistinct or incomplete connections
regarding relevance and workplace connections.
Identifies some of the key issues of the nature of the
collective bargaining dispute and some of the underlying causes of the dispute.
Some elements of the article are missing or inappropriately
identified.
Doesn’t identify at least the nature of the collective
bargaining dispute and the underlying causes of the dispute.
The topic is loosely connected; linkages not made; fails to
identify relevance.
Criteria 2
Exceeds Expectations
5 points
Meets Expectations
4 points
Meets Some Expectations
3 points
Does Not Meet Expectations
2 points
Not Included
0 points
Identifies the economic or ethical pressures each side has
attempted to use to prevail in the dispute
Identifies the economic or ethical pressures each side has
attempted to use to prevail in the dispute.Makes strong, logical connections
Identifies some the economic or ethical pressures each side
has attempted to use to prevail in the dispute. Makes some logical connections.
Identifies at least some of the economic or ethical
pressures each side has attempted to use to prevail in the dispute. Makes some
loose connections.
Little or no identification of the economic or ethical
pressures each side has attempted to use to prevail in the dispute. Makes no
logical connections.
Criteria 3
Exceeds Expectations
5 points
Meets Expectations
4 points
Meets Some Expectations
3 points
Does Not Meet Expectations
2 points
Not Included
0 points
What, if any, role was played by third parties in resolving
this bargaining dispute? What was the identity of the third party?
Discussed the role, if any, played by third parties in
resolving this dispute and identified the third party. Reader can easily follow the author’s logic
and flow.
Discussed, although not comprehensively, the role, if any,
played by third parties in resolving this dispute and identified the third
party. While overall well-organized, at times the writing forces the reader to
determine the author’s train of thought.
Discussed the role, if any, played by third parties in
resolving this dispute; however, did not identify a third party. Consistent organization is lacking causing
the reader to have difficulty in following the author’s train of thought.
Did not discuss the role, if any, played by third parties in
resolving this dispute and didn’t discuss or identify a third party.
Paper lacks a sense of organization or plan to the
presentation of ideas.
Criteria 4
Exceeds Expectations
5 points
Meets Expectations
4 points
Meets Some Expectations
3 points
Does Not Meet Expectations
2 points
Not Included
0 points
Was the dispute resolved? In retrospect, could this dispute
have been resolved in a more constructive fashion? If so, how?
Discussed if the dispute was resolved and if it could have
been resolved in a more constructive manner
Reader can easily follow the author’s logic and flow.
Discussed, although not comprehensively, if the dispute was
resolved and if it could have been resolved in a more constructive manner.
While overall well-organized, at times the writing forces
the reader to determine the author’s train of thought.
Discussed if the dispute was resolved although not if it
could have been resolved in a more constructive manner.
Consistent organization is lacking causing the reader to
have difficulty in following the author’s train of thought.
Did not discuss if
the dispute was resolved or not and didn’t suggest if it could have been
resolved in a constructive manner.
Paper lacks a sense of organization or plan to the
presentation of ideas.
Criteria 5
Exceeds Expectations
5 points
Meets Expectations
4 points
Meets Some Expectations
3 points
Does Not Meet Expectations
2 points
Not Included
0 points
Use of current and relevant sources, citation and mechanics.
The author has identified and selected a minimum of three
very appropriate and current resources.
The author has identified and selected at least two sources
that are appropriate for this assignment.
The author has identified and selected one source that is
commercial rather than academic or from a business sources such as vendor Web
sites.
The author has not identified or selected an article that is
appropriate; it is commercial rather than academic or from a business sources
such as vendor Web sites.
Accurate use of APA style for in-text citations and
References
The paper correctly cites in-text and lists resources on the
References page. If additional sources
are used, they are included correctly.
The majority of in-text citations and the reference are
properly cited; formatting is inconsistent / inaccurate in a few cases.
References are cited but incorrectly under APA style. The
student has either used another format or incorrectly applied the APA style
guidelines.
Inconsistent or missing in-text citations; fails to
attribute an author’s word through APA citations.
25 POSSIBLE TOTAL POINTS
/25
Attachments
