SOCI 215 Social Deviance
Assignment 2:
Deviance – Experiential Learning – Due by 11:55pm ET on Sunday of Week 7
Assignment Overview:
Social interaction proceeds fluidly in everyday life,
because people have shared definitions of and expectations about routine
situations. As we go about our day, we generally assume that people are going
to behave a certain way and observe certain norms. When they don’t, we may
sometimes know how to respond, because we have seen that kind of violation
before. For example, if someone cuts in front of us in line, we probably
already know how we would react to that breach of common courtesy.
But other norms are so ingrained and automatic that we can
hardly imagine anyone breaking them. Because we have never been confronted with
the behavior, we have no pre-set idea of how to react when someone fails to
behave “normally.” For instance, if you were sitting in a near-empty
movie theater and a stranger suddenly sat down directly beside you, how would
you react? Chances are, you have no idea, because it’s just not something
people do.
This assignment calls for you to breach a social norm,
either by doing something one is not supposed to do, OR by not doing something
that is considered standard behavior in that particular situation.
ALTERNATIVE ASSIGNMENT:
If you are physically unable to perform any type of norm
breaching experiment, you may analyze an example of norm breaching in the media
in a film, television show, literary novel, or other form of media. Directions
given below.
Assignment Instructions: Preparation
1) Think of a social
norm to violate. It should be a situation where everyone knows what the
appropriate behavior would be without having to think about it, with the
limitation that it cannot be anything illegal or harmful to yourself or others:
we are examining LEGAL deviance only in this assignment.
You may find this site to be helpful in thinking about
social norm violations. It gives information on the norm breaching experiments
of Harold Garfinkel and others who studied this phenomenon:
https://www.revolvy.com/main/index.php?s=Breaching%20experiment
2) Violate the norm
you chose over a long enough time to permit yourself to observe at least three
reactions from others. (If you are having trouble getting people to react, then
your behavior isn’t really a norm violation, and you should try a different
one.) Important: do not tell anyone what you are doing, or that this is an
assignment. You should behave as if what you are doing is normal to you. You
should bring something to write on such as a cell phone or notebook so that you
can take notes on other people’s reactions and your own personal feelings
throughout the process. When you are finished, your task is to develop a 5 page
paper write-up about this experiment (not including title and reference pages).
FOR ALTERNATIVE ASSIGNMENT:
Think of a social norm that you have seen violated in a
film, television show, literary novel, or other form of media. It should be a
situation where everyone knows what the appropriate behavior would be without
having to think about it, with the exception of the character who is violating
the norm.
You may find this site to be helpful in thinking about
social norm violations. It gives information on the norm breaching experiments
of Harold Garfinkel and others who studied this phenomenon:
https://www.revolvy.com/main/index.php?s=Breaching%20experiment
Observe this norm violation in the media you selected long
enough to note at least three reactions from other characters. You should have
something to write on such as a cell phone or notebook so that you can take
notes about other people’s reactions and your own personal feelings throughout
the process. When you are finished, your task is to develop a 5 page paper
write-up about this experiment (not including title and reference pages).
Assignment Instructions: Paper
1) In your paper, under the subheading of Method: Include a
1 paragraph overview explaining what you did and how you did it. Explain which norm you violated—i.e., what is
normally done vs. what you did differently.
2) Under the subheading of Findings: Include a 1 page
analysis that includes:
Your personal feelings: how did you feel before engaging in
your norm violation, during it, and afterward?
Other people’s reactions during the violation. Did anything
unusual or substantial happen because of the norm violation? How did you know
what people were thinking and feeling about the violation? Were there any
notable patterns that arose in people’s reactions?
3) Under the subheading of Discussion: Include a 4 page
analysis in which you reflect on your findings. Using the course concepts and
ideas discussed and read thus far, how can you understand and interpret the
interactions of others? How can you
understand your own experience/feelings about norm breaching? In this discussion, you must:
Clearly apply at least 3 relevant sociological
concepts/theories from our course materials/readings to the deviant behavior
you analyzed in this experiment.
Clearly apply findings from at least 5 meaningful up-to-date
resources, 3 of which are from reputable academic journals, to the deviant
behavior you analyzed in this experiment.
NOTE: do not include the actual notes you took during the
observations. You need to analyze and discuss the notes, but not include/list
them in your paper.
Do not use unverifiable, secondary sites such as Wikipedia,
about.com, ask.com, and similar. Use our course materials, peer-reviewed
journal articles from the library, and other scholarly sources.
Your presentation should utilize sound critical thought and
it should include appropriate APA in-text citations and full APA references at
the end.
FOR ALTERNATIVE ASSIGNMENT:
In your paper, under the subheading of Method: Include a 1
paragraph overview explaining what media you analyzed. Explain which norm was
violated—i.e., what is normally done vs. what was done differently.
2) Under the subheading of Findings: Include a 1 page
analysis that includes:
Your personal feelings: how did you feel while observing the
norm violation during it, and afterward?
Other people’s reactions during the violation. Did anything
unusual or substantial happen because of the norm violation? How did you know
what other characters were thinking and feeling about the violation? Were there
any notable patterns that arose in people’s reactions?
3) Under the subheading
of Discussion: Include a 4 page analysis in which you reflect on your findings.
Using the course concepts and ideas discussed and read thus far, how can you
understand and interpret the interactions of others? How can you understand your own experience/feelings
about norm breaching? In this
discussion, you must:
Clearly apply at least 3 relevant sociological
concepts/theories from our course materials/readings to the deviant behavior
you analyzed in this experiment.
Clearly apply findings from at least 5 meaningful up-to-date
resources, 3 of which are from reputable academic journals, to the deviant
behavior you analyzed in this experiment.
NOTE: do not include the actual notes you took during the
observations. You need to analyze and discuss the notes, but not include/list
them in your paper.
Do not use unverifiable, secondary sites such as Wikipedia,
about.com, ask.com, and similar. Use our course materials, peer-reviewed
journal articles from the library, and other scholarly sources.
Your presentation should utilize sound critical thought and
it should include appropriate APA in-text citations and full APA references at
the end.
