Price discrimination vs. perfectly competitive market
1. Suppose a monopolist could perfectly price discriminate
(i.e., this would be 1st degree price discrimination). Compare the consumer
surplus, producer surplus, and total surplus in this situation to those same
measures in a perfectly competitive market.
2. In a large number of cities around the world, the local,
tax-supported fire department has a monopoly on putting out fires. Suppose the
mayor of your town believes monopolies are bad. He proposes to eliminate the
fire department and have the market assume control.
Briefly, but with some detail, outline what the mayor must
mean by having the market assume control (the more specific, the better). Then
briefly discuss the merits of having a monopoly in charge and the merits of
having the market put out fires. It might be helpful to answer this question by
setting up a simple example. For instance, imagine that you live in a
residential neighborhood of the city in question and your house begins to
smolder. Assume that you are unable to put the fire out yourself-you need some
help.
